Their competing legacies, like the twin strands of dna, continue to shape our country to this day. Compare and contrast the hamilton and jefferson debates. The rivalry that forged a nation is another masterpiece penned by the eminent revolutionary war historian john ferling this book is a must read for anyone interested in the history of the united states, especially the revolutionary war period. Federalist and the democratic republican parties, respectively. These disagreements led to the creation of the nations first two political parties federalists and republicans. The hamilton broadway musical uber hit of the 21st century may leave one with the impression that hamilton was well loved during his historical time. Comparing the ideals of hamilton and jefferson 1 dlrections. July 11 is the anniversary of the 1804 duel in which alexander hamilton was fatally shot by vice president aaron burr. He made a name for himself during this period by combining. How does jefferson s interpretation of the elastic necessary and proper clause reflect his strict constructionist beliefs regarding the constitution. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Jefferson free printable reading with questions for high school united states history students. Hamilton, madison, and their allies did everything in their power to destroy hamilton s reputation including the initiation of a corruption investigation. Hamilton thought jefferson was foolishly idealistic.
Jefferson washington concerned about the constitutionality of the united states bank, asked jefferson and hamilton each. The case for alexander hamilton s vision we live, without question, in hamilton s america, says stephen f. Hamilton is not a comparative study of jefferson and hamilton. Chapter 4 hamilton, jefferson, and the first national bank of. No other statesman has personified national power and the rule of the favored few so well as hamilton, and no other has glorified selfgovernment and the. Thomas jefferson versus alexander hamilton read the information about jefferson and hamilton s differing views about government. Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson were both appointed to george washingtons cabinet, despite differing opinions on the role of the government. Hamiltons demise would soon come from burr, however, in a deadly duel. Timetoasts free timeline maker lets you create timelines online. Rather, this work consists of excerpts from the papers of thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton and the authors commentary on the selected papers. Copy of jefferson letter to washington copy of hamilton letter to washington copy of hamilton vs. Chapter 2 hamilton and jefferson the men and their.
Hamiltons america and the rise of progressivism in contrast to jeffersons. Hamilton wrote numerous newspaper articles under pseudonyms trying to destroy jefferson. On todays episode, we pick up where the musical hamilton left off, and explore what happened to vice president burr in the aftermath of the duel. In this box, explain why southern states agreed to the creation of the bank of the united states. You can edit this venn diagram using creately diagramming tool and include in your reportpresentationwebsite. Established in its earliest form in 1824, the university officially combined with philadelphia university in 2017. Then fill out the venn diagram summarizing their likes and differences. It ended only with the death of hamilton in a pistol duel, felled by aaron burr, jefferson s vice president.
Alexander hamilton federalists thomas jefferson democraticrepublicans states rights loose v. The federalists, led by alexander hamilton, advocated the importance of a strong central government in leading the country forward, while the democratic republicans, led by thomas jefferson, promoted increasing the common mans role. With land inherited from his father, jefferson set himself up as a virginia tobacco farmer. What was the conflict compare and contrast the hamilton and jefferson debates. Home george washington first president washingtons presidential jefferson and hamilton, political differences of opinion didnt concern president washington. Hamilton and the federalists wanted the young nation to become a. These two adversaries battled over the role of the government and the economy during the first years of the nation. Jefferson alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson were both important founding fathers in the early days of the american nation, yet they despised each other. Eventually, hamilton would help jefferson become elected as the third president as he hated the opponent, aaron burr someone he held as a man with no principles greater than jefferson someone with policies and beliefs different than him. Hamilton younger than jefferson by 12 years did not trust the general public. Opposed ratification feared a strong central government would infringe on the rights of states and individuals.
Felt that most people were motivated by their passions and selfinterest. Comparing the ideas of hamilton and jefferson flashcards. Answer this in a complete sentence somewhere on your note sheet 2. As such, he had a very comfortable childhood devoid of any financial constraints. He died with burrs bullet in his chest in weehawken, new jersey, on july 12, 1804.
Jefferson debate has been going on for two centuries, and will probably continue through the life of the nation. Thomas jefferson unlike hamilton, thomas jefferson was an aristocrat by birth and a democrat by conviction. Engaging with the two positions helps us clarify our own beliefs about what the united states is and should be. The great bank debate how should the united states take care of its money. Check out our top free essays on compare and contrast jefferson and hamilton to help you write your own essay. A 10year perspective of the merger of louisville and. Cunningham presents this series of selected writings by jefferson and hamilton as a mirror image of the. Read this american history essay and over 89,000 other research documents. Complete tm chart below tor the hlsloncal figure your group created a poster about. Hamilton star daveed diggs explains how thomas jefferson planted all those crops duration.
The antifederalists supported jefferson, and the federalists supported hamilton. Free essays on compare and contrast jefferson and hamilton. What danger does jefferson see in congress adopting hamilton s plans for a national bank. Jefferson reading with questions student handouts a conflict took shape in the 1790s between americas first political parties. Politics and the misadventures of thomas jeffersons modern. Conference did the character strengths of hamilton and. The people are turbulent and changing, he wrote in 1787, they seldom judge or determine right. Thomas jefferson, born rich in virginia, was a slave owner who served as the first secretary of state. This unit is meant to provide students with enduring knowledge about the.
This is a bundle of products that will be helpful in teaching the first two party system and the conflicts between thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton in the 1790s. To analyze the differences between the first political parties. Hamilton vs jefferson thomas jefferson vs alexander hamilton. A modern perspective on hamilton and jefferson ideaexchange. Unfortunately, george washington thought theyd be great together and put hamilton as his secretary of the treasury and jefferson as secretary of state.
Article i, section 8 of the constitution allows congress. Difference between hamilton and jefferson compare the. Jefferson brought one of his greatest achievements to america as a whole in contrast too hamilton. Read the information about jefferson and hamilton s differing views about government. What is clear from contemporaries and contemporaneous writings for hamilton s period is that hamilton and adams jefferson had distinct differences on the constitution, and future direction of these united states of america. Hamilton and jefferson document based question american history grade 11 regular. Speculate on how jefferson and hamilton might react to the current conditions in american domestic and foreign affairs. Hamilton and jefferson the men and their philosophies e was born with a silver spoon in his mouth, yet he claimed to speak for the vast majority of average americans and not the wealthy. Alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson an enduring dialogue submitted by. We will be concerned with two leaders, jefferson and hamilton, both seeking after. Pdf balancing hamiltonian and jeffersonian contradictions. Students learn about two of the leaders in these parties. Compare and contrast the social, political, and economic philosophies of thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton.
It is a great way to distinguish between different perspectives or to show parallels in different pieces of literature. Thomas jefferson university is a private university in philadelphia, pennsylvania. Bell ringer why did many people oppose the economic plan of alexander hamilton. Jefferson resigned as secretary of state under washington to form his.
It was necessary for jefferson to ensure that every state be given equal amounts of freedom, unconstrained by the functions of the federal government. Hamilton s great aim was more efficient organization, whereas jefferson once said i am not a friend to a very energetic government. The first twoparty system federalists leaders jeffersonian republicans federalism fears constitution support base gov involvement in economy national bank protective tariff of state federal assumption war debts foreign policy for more instructional materials, visit my website. Hamilton and jefferson were popular members of the society in the period after the revolution. A conflict took shape in the 1790s between americas first political parties. This critical issue serves as a dividing line between hamilton s federalists and jefferson s democraticrepublicans.
Jefferson county on january 1st, 2003, is the most recent example of a citycounty consolidation executed by a major american city. This called into question the strength of madisons character and. After analyzing both hamilton and jeffersons ideas and political views towards economical reformation my group came to a conclusion that jefferson provided america with the correct reformation. Read the information about jefferson and hamiltons differing views about government. They both showed difference between them, when it comes to their thoughts and ideas.
Political parties began to form around jefferson s and hamilton s views of the constitution. Put an asterisk next to the components of the plan that were approved by congress. Alexander hamilton introduction thomas jefferson was born on april, 1743 in virginia. Debate rules no put downs you must raise your hand if its not your turn to speak lose 1 point for each interruption lose 1 point for any whispering while another speaker is talking debate process 1. He owned slaves, but wrote the declaration of independence declaring that all men were born with godgiven, unalienable rights. Although hamilton and jefferson contemplated issues related to the governance of the united states, the authors argue that their writings offer insights that can be. Citizen genet and foreign policy jefferson was a states rights supporter and opposed hamilton s national bank. Alexander hamilton vs thomas jefferson chart thomas jefferson. As a politician, he did not have the ability to make rousing speeches. Jefferson vs hamilton state power and federal power learn more about this topic. Once established as a planter, jefferson entered virginia politics. Curriculum unit virginia turner barnstable unit overview was the vision for the united states ever truly united.
A poem for two voices is a poem in which two points of view are talking at the same time. George washington, thomas jefferson, and alexander hamilton and an. Jefferson feared tyranny and thought in terms of freedom. This report examines how louisville metro has performed over the past decade since the merger took effect by analyzing the citys economy, population. These disagreements quickly split american political leaders into two groups. By doing this, many historians and even his contemporaries, including hamilton, argue that madison too easily deserted his own principles for those of a more liberal thomas jefferson. Even though washington sought to maintain unity, a division emerged within his cabinet between hamilton and jefferson.
Whose vision of america won outhamiltons or jeffersons. Thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton were two very influential people with very different ideals. Read each section, and then respond by answering the question or taking notes on key ideas. Jefferson then crystallized his case by merging the local business. The evolution of james madison and alexander hamiltons. Thomas jefferson seemed to disagree on everything from the economy, the national debt, states rights, trade, how to interpret the constitution, and whether to support britain or france. Hamilton accepted when burr challenged him to a duel. Hamiltonian vs jeffersonian democracies 5550 words. How could you compare and contrast thomas jefferson and. Thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton differed in that hamilton believed in the idea of a strong government with huge oversight with voters limited to those of appropriate educational backgrounds, while jefferson believed in the idea of a small government with minimal.
Heres a brief summary of the two positions, if youre interested. Knott, professor of national security affairs at shows this day in history. Hamilton feared anarchy and thought in terms of order. Thomas jefferson to george washington, may 23, 1792 and alexander hamilton to edward carrington, may 26, 1792 in jefferson vs. Engage your students during remote learning with video readalouds. Washington concerned about the constitutionality of the united states bank, asked jefferson and hamilton each to give their opinions on the. Read the psten the other groups made md recod your findings on the chart low i. Download george washington, thomas jefferson, and alexander. Read the section of the textbook that describes the differences between alexander hamilton and thomas jefferson you find it look at the index. Oct 31, 2016 hamilton favored a strong, active, and energetic central government, while jefferson advocated for a limited federal government that would respect the rights of the states. They could even be useful, until he came to realize in 1792, the very personal nature of the differences between two of his cabinet members. Indeed, the federalists, led by alexander hamilton, and the republicans also called democraticrepublicans, led by thomas jefferson, were the first political parties in the western world. How could you compare and contrast thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton.
How did the political beliefs of hamilton and jefferson translate into policies. Chapter 2 hamilton and jefferson the men and their philosophies. Make educational timelines or create a timeline for your company website. Jefferson and hamilton quotes it would reduce the whole instrument to a single phrase, that of instituting a congress with power to do whatever would be for the good of the united states. George washington did in his will or joining an antislavery organization.
John adams sided with the federalists in spite of some personal and political disagreements with hamilton, while jefferson was joined by his close friend, james madison. Secretary hamiltons plan to assume state debt and establish a. Jefferson, by contrast, had supreme faith in the electorate and wished to guarantee the survival of liberty by improving the education of the common people. Hamilton was found innocent of corruption, but was guilty of the nations first government sex scandal. Nevertheless, hamilton worked hard and effectively in getting the constitution ratified in new york. Each section gives more detail on one of the lyrics from the song. Jefferson and hamilton is the story of the fierce struggleboth public and, ultimately, bitterly personalbetween these two titans. At age 14, the young jefferson inherited his fathers plantation and slaves. This nearpod authors lesson compares the views of the first two political partiesthe federalists and the democratic republicans. Thomas jefferson democracy is defined as, a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held free elections merriamwebster. Hamilton thomas jefferson and alexander hamilton were two very influential people with very different ideals. His mother came from one of the famous families in virginia.
982 1203 1393 1403 1144 60 1310 805 544 595 697 1367 1015 215 1182 739 179 353 141 260 996 184 589 259 1109 377 655 1395 151 380 1403 660 264